Your child claims that he or she does not remember screaming at you when they got angry. Your spouse claims that he or she does not remember saying those hurtful things in your heated discussion. You can’t recall how you got so angry that you acted completely out of character. Sound familiar? Most people have experienced at least one instance in which the emotion of anger was associated with loss of recall. Does anger really cause memory loss? Or is lack of memory simply a defense mechanism that people use to avoid accountability? Perspective about anger’s impact on memory matters.
The brain is a very complex organ. To simplify the parts of the brain pertinent to this discussion, the hand model of the brain is helpful. The hand model demonstrates two key parts of the brain pertinent to this discussion: the thinking brain, or lid; and the amygdala, or the fight/flight/freeze part (Siegel, 2017). When not under threat or “regulated,” the thinking brain and amygdala work together. When under threat or “dysregulated,” the thinking brain and amygdala struggle to remain integrated. This is what happens when a person is flooded with feelings of anger. The thinking brain disconnects, or the lid flips, leaving only the lower, bottom parts of the brain (associated with survival) to run the show (BBB Australia, 2019). Communication begins to struggle. Emotional control wanes or disappears. Most of the time reasoning fails to register. The brain is not useless; it is just protecting itself by staying in survival mode.
In survival mode, the brain focuses on the threat. Maintaining focus on the threat can cause a person to not acknowledge other things that are happening (CogniFit, n.d.). This may present as memory loss, but is in fact not actual memory loss, as the stimuli never registered in the first place. To maintain focus on the threat, the brain also releases a chemical called cortisol (Frank, as cited in Steber, 2017). Studies have shown that cortisol interferes with consolidating and retrieving memories, which may present, at least in the short term, as memory loss (Jian et al., 2019). Counselor Rebecca Frank states that “elevated cortisol … disrupts the creation of new memories and suppresses activity in the hippocampus, which weakens short-term memory. It also prevents you from forming new memories properly. That’s why highly stressful situation[s] are harder to remember.” (Frank)
Repeated and sustained doses of cortisol can not only interfere with memory but can also lead to memory deficits and decrease volume of the hippocampus (Souza-Talarico et al., 2011). The hippocampus is part of learning and memory, so while this does not point to memory loss directly, it may impact it.
In summary, is it possible that an angry person does not remember what was said or done when angry? Yes. Is it possible that the memory of the moment is lost? Maybe. Maybe not. It may not be accessible at certain times.
Recognizing that anger affects brain functioning and memory is crucial to starting to understand anger and for coping with anger. Badgering a person about what you know happened in that fight might not be very helpful. What might be more helpful is working with the person to reconnect the thinking brain so that new, more positive ways of functioning can be learned and initiated going forward. Keeping the brain engaged is the best predictor of accountability, which is what is needed if actions are to eventually change.
Your child claims that he or she does not remember screaming at you when they got angry. Your spouse claims that he or she does not remember saying those hurtful things in your heated discussion. You can’t recall how you got so angry that you acted completely out of character. Sound familiar? Most people have experienced at least one instance in which the emotion of anger was associated with loss of recall. Does anger really cause memory loss? Or is lack of memory simply a defense mechanism that people use to avoid accountability? Perspective about anger’s impact on memory matters.
The brain is a very complex organ. To simplify the parts of the brain pertinent to this discussion, the hand model of the brain is helpful. The hand model demonstrates two key parts of the brain pertinent to this discussion: the thinking brain, or lid; and the amygdala, or the fight/flight/freeze part (Siegel, 2017). When not under threat or “regulated,” the thinking brain and amygdala work together. When under threat or “dysregulated,” the thinking brain and amygdala struggle to remain integrated. This is what happens when a person is flooded with feelings of anger. The thinking brain disconnects, or the lid flips, leaving only the lower, bottom parts of the brain (associated with survival) to run the show (BBB Australia, 2019). Communication begins to struggle. Emotional control wanes or disappears. Most of the time reasoning fails to register. The brain is not useless; it is just protecting itself by staying in survival mode.
In survival mode, the brain focuses on the threat. Maintaining focus on the threat can cause a person to not acknowledge other things that are happening (CogniFit, n.d.). This may present as memory loss, but is in fact not actual memory loss, as the stimuli never registered in the first place. To maintain focus on the threat, the brain also releases a chemical called cortisol (Frank, as cited in Steber, 2017). Studies have shown that cortisol interferes with consolidating and retrieving memories, which may present, at least in the short term, as memory loss (Jian et al., 2019). Counselor Rebecca Frank states that “elevated cortisol … disrupts the creation of new memories and suppresses activity in the hippocampus, which weakens short-term memory. It also prevents you from forming new memories properly. That’s why highly stressful situation[s] are harder to remember.” (Frank)
Repeated and sustained doses of cortisol can not only interfere with memory but can also lead to memory deficits and decrease volume of the hippocampus (Souza-Talarico et al., 2011). The hippocampus is part of learning and memory, so while this does not point to memory loss directly, it may impact it.
In summary, is it possible that an angry person does not remember what was said or done when angry? Yes. Is it possible that the memory of the moment is lost? Maybe. Maybe not. It may not be accessible at certain times.
Recognizing that anger affects brain functioning and memory is crucial to starting to understand anger and for coping with anger. Badgering a person about what you know happened in that fight might not be very helpful. What might be more helpful is working with the person to reconnect the thinking brain so that new, more positive ways of functioning can be learned and initiated going forward. Keeping the brain engaged is the best predictor of accountability, which is what is needed if actions are to eventually change.
References
BBB Australia. (2019, December 24). Our reaction to stress explained: How to use ‘The hand model of the brain.’” Building Better Brains: Together We Can.
CogniFit. (n.d.) Memory loss.
Jiang, A., Tran, T. T., Madison, F. N., & Bakker, A. (2019). Acute stress-induced cortisol elevation during memory consolidation enhances pattern separation. Learning & Memory, 26(4), 121–127.
Siegel, D. (2017, August 7). Dr. Dan Siegel’s hand model of the brain [Video]. YouTube.
Souza-Talarico, J. N., Marin, M.-F., Sindi, S., & Lupien, S. J. (2011). Effects of stress hormones on the brain and cognition: Evidence from normal to pathological aging. Dementia & Neuropsychologia, 5(1), 8–16.
Steber, C. (2017, November 6). Weird things that can happen to your body when you’re angry. Bustle.
References
BBB Australia. (2019, December 24). Our reaction to stress explained: How to use ‘The hand model of the brain.’” Building Better Brains: Together We Can.
CogniFit. (n.d.) Memory loss.
Jiang, A., Tran, T. T., Madison, F. N., & Bakker, A. (2019). Acute stress-induced cortisol elevation during memory consolidation enhances pattern separation. Learning & Memory, 26(4), 121–127.
Siegel, D. (2017, August 7). Dr. Dan Siegel’s hand model of the brain [Video]. YouTube.
Souza-Talarico, J. N., Marin, M.-F., Sindi, S., & Lupien, S. J. (2011). Effects of stress hormones on the brain and cognition: Evidence from normal to pathological aging. Dementia & Neuropsychologia, 5(1), 8–16.
Steber, C. (2017, November 6). Weird things that can happen to your body when you’re angry. Bustle.